Shamanic trance vs. psychedelics

Distinct states with shared traits

Author | Lauren Talley

illustration of an orange sun behind pale yellow clouds

As part of their investigation of psychedelics for use in medicine, researchers at U-M are looking at how other altered states of consciousness produce similar experiences to those of psychedelics. One of them is shamanism.

“Shamanism is one of the world’s oldest spiritual practices,” says Emma Huels, a doctoral candidate in the Neuroscience Graduate Program at U-M. “It’s been around since the paleolithic era,” she says. “And to enter this state you’ll have a shaman, in the case of indigenous tribes, or a shamanic practitioner who has trained in these traditions. They enter this trance state by listening to rhythmic drumming, during which they provide healing to others. Our research is based on these healing practices started and still performed by indigenous cultures around the world.”

Huels and a team of researchers wanted to know whether the shamanic state of consciousness has similar effects on the brain as psychedelics. The research group studied 24 shamanic practitioners and 24 controls who had no previous exposure to shamanism or psychedelics. Using electroencephalography (EEG),they recorded brain activity during shamanic drumming and while listening to classical music. They then compared this data to previous studies measuring brain activity in people under the influence of psychedelics and published their findings in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience.

“We found that the way the brain changed in the practitioners whenever they were in this trance state was different than in psychedelics,” Huels says. However, the way people described their experience was similar to what was experienced by people in a psychedelic state despite the difference in brain activity.

“We call them distinct states with shared traits,”Huels says.

Huels is hopeful. With more research, reaching an altered state of consciousness through shamanism could become part of the standard array of non-pharmacological therapy options.


More Articles About: Research
Featured News & Stories Minding Memory with a microphone and a shadow of a microphone on a blue background
Minding Memory
The Impact of Partner Plan Choices among Older Adults Enrolled in Medicare Advantage (MMs4)
In this episode, Matt & Lauren speak with Dr. Lianlian Lei, an Assistant Professor in the Department of Psychiatry at the University of Michigan. Dr. Lei discusses a recent study that looks at the impact of partner’s plan choice on the likelihood of Medicare Advantage disenrollment and how that may impact older adults living with dementia. Unlike traditional Medicare that's administered by the federal government, Medicare Advantage are healthcare plans that are administered by private health insurance companies. These plans can vary a lot and typically cover additional services not covered by traditional Medicare. Navigating the various plan options can be a challenge for older adults, and it's not uncommon for individuals to change plans depending on their current needs.
Minding Memory with a microphone and a shadow of a microphone on a blue background
Minding Memory
The Return of Minding Memory
Welcome to Season 4 of Minding Memory, where we are welcoming a new co-host, Lauren Gerlach to the Minding Memory team. Lauren is a Geriatric Psychiatrist at the University of Michigan and a member of the CAPRA leadership team. In this episode, Lauren shares a little background on her research interests, what it’s like to be a geriatric psychiatrist, and some lessons learned about using “uncool” emoticons or emojis when texting.
Health Lab Podcast in brackets with a background with a dark blue translucent layers over cells
Health Lab Podcast
Addressing health care inequality
An expert on racial and ethnic differences in health care and health outcomes offers recommendations as part of a national committee.
Health Lab Podcast in brackets with a background with a dark blue translucent layers over cells
Health Lab Podcast
Presenting: The Fundamentals
Today on Health Lab, we are sharing an episode of The Fundamentals, another podcast from the Michigan Medicine Podcast Network that just launched its second season earlier this month. On this episode of The Fundamentals: "Cannabis and psychedelics: stigmatized substances or powerful therapeutics?" Dr. Kevin Boehnke talks about cannabis, psychedelics, and the increasing body of evidence for their legitimization as therapeutics.
The Fundamentals Podcast Hero Card Final 1800 x 1350
The Fundamentals
Treating Diabetes & Weight: The Ozempic & Wegovy Effect
Today on The Fundamentals, our guest Dr. Martin Myers, Director of the U-M Elizabeth Weiser Caswell Diabetes Institute, discusses diabetes research in the context of Ozempic, Wegovy, and other drugs that are changing how people think about weight loss. You can learn more about Dr. Myers here, and you can follow the department of molecular and integrative physiology @UMPhysiology on X.
The Fundamentals Podcast Hero Card Final 1800 x 1350
The Fundamentals
Can AI Make Us Healthier Humans?
Dr. Jody Platt. She is an Associate Professor of Learning Health Sciences at the University of Michigan Medical School. Trained in medical sociology and health policy, her research focuses on issues at the intersection of informatics and ethics. She is interested in understanding what makes data-driven health trusted, and the pathways for earning, achieving, and sustaining trust across stakeholders. Dr. Platt is the Academy Health and ABIM Foundation Senior Scholar in Residence advising on issues of measuring and building trust.